================================================================ Journal of Symbolic Computation Referee Report Form http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jsc Paper Identification -------------------- JSC ID : Title : Author Name : Tutorial (Y/N) : Referee Info ------------ Name : Email : Expertise area : Judgment --------- (1 Excellent; 2 Good; 3 Average; 4 Below Average; 5 Poor) * Relevance to the field of symbolic computation : * Originality (does not apply to tutorial papers) : * Nontriviality : * Logical and formal correctness : * Proper crediting/citing of previous literature : * Clarity, structure and style of presentation : * English grammar/spelling : Recommendation (Accept/Revise/Reject) : Comments to the editor (Confidential) ------------------------------------- Comments to the author ---------------------- ================================================================